Teacher, coach pleaded not guilty to the charges Friday
BLOOMFIELD -- The Bloomfield High School teacher and cross country coach accused of sexually assaulting two teenage boys was suspended from his teaching job and removed from his position at a local church, officials confirmed Friday.
Leo Donaldson, 30, formerly known as Leo Inglima, was suspended with pay in light of the allegations, said Nicholas Dotoli, director of administration and general counsel for the Bloomfield Board of Education. Policy dictates that Donaldson, a tenured teacher, would face suspension without pay if he is indicted on the charges.
Donaldson's lawyer Peter Gilbreth entered not guilty pleas to all charges against his client at a Friday hearing in Essex County Central Judicial Processing court. Gilbreth said he could not immediately comment on the allegations while he awaited documents from prosecutors.
The educator was also removed from positions as a parish cantor and youth minister at St. Francis of Assisi American National Catholic Church in Glen Ridge, according to a church statement. ANCC maintains a zero-tolerance policy toward "actual or alleged sexual misconduct on the part of either laity and clergy," the statement said.
"All lay and ordained persons in the ANCC who minister to children are required, as Mr. Donaldson was, to have background checks," church spokesman Father Kerry Walters added. "They're also required to abide by Church policy which stipulates that at least two adults must be present in parish activities involving children."
Meanwhile on Friday, Bloomfield school officials detailed the district's response to the allegations against the well-known teacher and coach. Dotoli, the school board attorney, said officials were alerted Oct. 20 that an arrest warrant was issued for Donaldson.
N.J. teacher, coach charged with sex assault of teens
Authorities did not reveal details about the warrant, including the exact charges, Dotoli said in an interview. Donaldson was absent from work at the time and under medical care, and he would have been arrested if he showed up on school property.
Citing the active investigation, Dotoli said the district was not informed about the specific charges when they first learned of the warrant. School officials, however, knew to make sure Donaldson was not allowed to be at school or participate in extracurricular events, he added.
Dotoli stressed the district did everything it could while working with limited information and not interfering with the criminal investigation. Donaldson was not back at school after the warrant was issued, he said.
Investigators did not immediately arrest the teacher because he was hospitalized and authorities knew where he was, said prosecutor's spokeswoman Katherine Carter.
Donaldson, who worked at the district for eight years, underwent a fingerprint criminal background check through the state Department of Education when he was hired, according to officials.
"It certainly can't predict any real or alleged criminal proclivities in the future," Dotoli said of the pre-employment background check, adding the district was not aware of any history of similar allegations involving Donaldson.
In addition to teaching architecture, Donaldson served as a peer leadership coordinator and coached track and cross-country. His entire career in Bloomfield has been at the high school, Dotoli added.
"Mr. Donaldson was an ambassador of sorts over at the high school," he said. "It's a very unfortunate situation."
Earlier this year, Donaldson was credited with saving the life of a student who collapsed during track practice, the Bloomfield Life reported in June.
Acting Essex County Prosecutor Carolyn A. Murray on Thursday announced Donaldson was charged with first-degree aggravated sexual assault, second-degree sexual assault by contact, third-degree aggravated criminal sexual contact and child endangerment. The assaults allegedly involved two boys ranging from 15 to 17 years old at Donaldson's Bloomfield home and his previous residence in Jersey City, according to prosecutors.
The teacher remained held at the Essex County jail in lieu of $500,000 cash only bail, the prosecutor's spokeswoman added. If Donaldson is released, he must stay away from the township high school, its students and staff, and the alleged victims and witnesses. Donaldson was set for another court hearing Dec. 2.
The prosecutor's office has asked anyone with information to call Capt. Steve Roberts at 973-753-1130.
Noah Cohen may be reached at ncohen@njadvancemedia.com. Follow him on Twitter @noahyc. Find NJ.com on Facebook.