The massively popular indie band from Montclair breaks its silence after nearly a year of hiatus
In November 2017, Pinegrove, the popular indie-rock band from Montclair, published a statement on its Facebook page announcing its singer had been accused of "sexual coercion" and that the band would enter into hiatus while the allegation was handled. The group then went silent for nearly a year.
But a new report, published Wednesday via a lengthy feature by Pitchfork, reveals new details on all that led up to the accusation against Evan Stephens Hall and the band's decision to take time off.
A mediator representing the band told Pitchfork the nature of alleged "sexual coercion" to be "verbal and contextual pressure" and that "the accusation is not of a physical nature at all."
Here's an excerpt from the Pitchfork report, further detailing the accusation, as told by the mediator and Hall himself:
"(The alleged victim) and (Hall) had a brief relationship, and she was in a relationship when it started. She felt that he coerced her into cheating on her partner with him, and she felt that she said no to him several times... and he continued to pursue her." Hall maintained that their relationship progressed mutually but acknowledged the alleged victim's "right to describe her experience however feels true to her." He added, "I definitely could have conducted myself better."
Hall says in the report that he felt pressured to explain his understanding of the coercion claim on Facebook due to a series of emails sent to the band from the Philadelphia-based organization Punk Talks, which, according to its website, "aims to connect music workers with affordable/free mental health treatment services." Punk Talks founder Sheridan Allen had been contacted by Hall's alleged victim, and if the band didn't cancel its upcoming tour, they were set to go public.
Hall reflects often in the Pitchfork piece: "I have been reflecting a lot about how a relationship that promotes honesty is an active process, and that maybe there are conversations we should have had that we didn't, or maybe there's something else I could have done to make her feel like she could have said how she was feeling," he said.
The band announced in the Pitchfork piece that its new album, "Skylight" -- which was finished before the allegation -- will be released independently of its record label, Run For Cover Records, on Friday. The band says it plans to resume performing live later this year.
Before the accusation came last fall, Pinegrove had advanced to indie-darling status, scoring rave reviews and more than 35 million listens on Spotify for its LPs "Everything So Far" (2015) and "Cardinal" (2016), the latter of which we discussed with Hall back in 2016 for NJ.com.
Bobby Olivier may be reached at bolivier@njadvancemedia.com. Follow him on Twitter @BobbyOlivier and Facebook. Find NJ.com on Facebook.