Andre Higgs is accused of attacking Latrena May on March 25, 2015 and then killing her on May 1
NEWARK -- At 10:22 p.m. on March 25, 2015, Latrena May called 911 to report that Andre Higgs, the father of her four-year-old daughter, had attacked May at her city home in front of the child.
In a shaky voice, May told the dispatcher Higgs left the home after he had "put his hands around my neck and he choked me in front of my daughter."
Less than two months later, Higgs is accused of fatally shooting May during an argument outside the Tremont Avenue home on May 1 while their daughter was inside the residence.
A recording of the 911 call was played Friday during a hearing on a motion by Essex County Assistant Prosecutor Justin Edwab to present evidence about the earlier alleged domestic dispute at Higgs's trial on murder and related charges in May's killing.
The hearing is scheduled to continue on April 15 before Superior Court Judge Ronald Wigler.
In the murder case, authorities have said Higgs and May were arguing on the porch of her home when May flagged down a police office patrolling the area. Higgs then shot her three times and the officer shot Higgs, authorities said.
After he was shot, Higgs went into the house with the weapon before he was apprehended, authorities said. A 27-year-old teacher at Pride Academy Charter School in East Orange, May was pronounced dead at the scene, authorities said.
Higgs, 43, of Watchung, was later released on $1 million bail. But after he was charged with causing a drunken crash on Christmas in Middlesex County, Wigler imposed a more stringent bail requirement in the murder case and Higgs was returned to the Essex County Correctional Facility in January.
During Friday's hearing, East Orange Detective Steven Plumer testified about what May told him when he and his partner were dispatched to her home on March 25 in response to her 911 call.
Plumer said May told him Higgs choked her on a couch in the living room and on the kitchen floor while her daughter was present. Plumer recalled seeing bruises on May's neck area.
According to Plumer, May said the altercation stemmed from Higgs's allegations that she was "sleeping with other men."
"She was almost in hysterics, very disheveled," said Plumer, referring to May. "Her face was puffy, her eyes were watery."
May also said Higgs "was gonna come back and kill her," Plumer said.
But on cross-examination, Higgs's attorney, Thomas Ashley, challenged Plumer's credibility by noting how Plumer's testimony was based on his own recollections and that he did not file a police report that documents his encounter with May. Other police officers later filed reports about the incident, Plumer said.
Ashley also pointed out how Plumer or other police officers did not take photos of May's alleged bruises.
"Did you document anything?" Ashley asked Plumer.
"Me personally?" Plumer replied.
"Yes," Ashley said.
"No, I did not," Plumer said.
Bill Wichert may be reached at bwichert@njadvancemedia.com. Follow him on Twitter @BillWichertNJ. Find NJ.com on Facebook.