Two factions of residents at Terrell Homes, a Newark public housing development, are divided
About whether the complex should closed.
The 32 residents of the Millard E. Terrell Homes wearing blue T-shirts with bold white lettering that read: We Want Out, listened as some of their neighbors told Newark City Council, that they want in.
Many who spoke during the meeting said they have lived at Terrell for as long as 50 years, raised their families there and don't want the Newark Housing Authority to close the public housing complex, despite its severe deterioration.
They simply don't want to leave, even though the housing authority says it will submit an application for demolition by March or April to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.
The residents in the blue We Want Out shirts, arrived too late to sign-in for an opportunity to speak at the meeting. So they held a silent protest, walking down the side aisle of council chambers, across the front and back up the center aisle past the podium with a microphone.
MORE: Recent Barry Carter columns
"I'm sure we got our point across,'' said Chakeya Martin, a Terrell resident for eight years.
The group says it made a last-minute decision to show up when they heard that long-time residents were going to attend the council meeting and request the complex remain open.
While one side speaks about Terrell being a family-oriented community in which they've grown accustomed, the residents who want to leave say their neighbors and the Ironbound Community Corporation, a nonprofit organization that provides an array of social services to residents, are just delaying the inevitable.
"It's the living conditions,'' said Chakeya Martin. "Nothing is meant to last forever.''
The Terrell Homes are falling apart. The electrical and boiler systems are antiquated. Apartments don't have showers. There are stubborn cases of mold that keep returning. Lead was removed by the EPA from the soil of the playground a few years ago. And, most concerning, the complex is rife with violent crime. Resident Valtina McRae was so concerned for the safety of her two children, she sent them to live with her sister.
"Somebody got shot in the building that I live in,'' she said. "I don't know why they want to stay there.''
NHA Executive Director Keith Kinard has said the 275 apartment complex is too expensive to maintain and that it would cost some $60 million to repair.
"The objective is to shut the community down because we can't afford to provide a decent, safe, sanitary environment,'' Kinard said.
It's a grim picture, and those ready to leave would be pleased if the housing agency could relocate them now. But they can't move until HUD approves the demolition application.
Tenant President Rita Fortenberry said residents shouldn't be divided on this issue. Even though she would like to stay, Fortenberry said, she wants all residents to have the best relocation options if the development is closed.
"We should all be one voice,'' she said. "I don't think we're being dealt with fairly. We're not going quietly.''
The Ironbound Community Corporation has called on the housing authority to make sure all residents have decent housing.
If HUD gives the okay to demolish the site, Kinard said, residents have the option to move to another housing authority property or receive section 8 vouchers, which would allow them to live anywhere they'd like. Either way, they would be reimbursed for moving expenses.
"But are those quality housing options?'' asked ICC Executive Director Joseph Della Fave. "The people of Terrell deserve better housing conditions regardless of where that may be.''
Residents are concerned that if they move to another public housing development, the agency could decide to shut it down one day for the same reasons that Terrell is being closed. Should that happen, both Fortenberry and Della Fave said, residents would find themselves back in the same predicament.
The die-hards say they want to remain in the Ironbound community, and Councilman Augusto Amadore said he would fight to help them remain in the East Ward.
"We need to provide the support for these tenants and make sure they are treated with dignity,'' he said at the council meeting.
MORE CARTER: Reopening of the Hahne's property in Newark brings back memories
Residents bent on staying believe the housing authority has allowed the property to fall into disrepair to the point where it can't be fixed. They speculate that once the Terrell Homes are gone, new homes will be constructed, and they won't be a part of the resurgence.
"They're just trying to get us out of this place,'' said Dorothy Brazell. "Somebody is going to buy this place.''
Kinard said there aren't any plans for redevelopment of the complex, which was built in 1946 and first called the Franklin D. Roosevelt Homes. It was renamed in 1986 after Millard E. Terrell, a housing commissioner and civic leader in Newark.
If history is any indication, it doesn't look good for the complex.
HUD has consistently approved the housing authority's demolition requests for its other aging complexes across the city.
Barry Carter: (973) 836-4925 or bcarter@starledger.com or nj.com barry carter or follow him on Twitter @BarryCarterSL