James Solomon stunned the establishment with his council victory on Dec. 5.
JERSEY CITY -- Stop us if you've heard this one before: a political neophyte and Jersey City transplant pledging to reform city government takes on the political establishment and becomes the Downtown Jersey City councilman in an upset.
That was the story Tuesday night, when James Solomon stunned Jersey City by winning the Ward E City Council seat. It was the same tale 12 years ago for Steve Fulop, now the mayor and a frequent target of Solomon's campaign for not living up to his promises of reform.
Solomon, 33, said he does not see himself as a councilman in Fulop's mold. Fulop rose to political prominence while the Ward E councilman, spending much of those eight years lobbing attacks at then-Mayor Jerramiah Healy before unseating Healy in 2013.
"The mayor and I agree on a lot and I don't think it's in the best interests of the people of Ward E for me to be a bomb thrower," Solomon said in an interview with The Jersey Journal. "I had clear policy differences with ... things that happened in the last four years, particularly around development, and I'm going to stay true to those themes and messages and try to push the city in a more progressive direction."
Political observers do not take Solomon at his word. They see an ambitious guy who will not hesitate to take on the mayor for political gain.
"He's going to torture Steve," one source said.
Solomon, a Democrat who hails from Millburn, moved to Jersey City with his wife in 2014. He teaches politics and government at New Jersey City University and Hudson County Community College and was a 2015 fellow with New Leaders Council, a training ground for young, politically ambitious progressives.
He made waves locally urging city officials not to award tax breaks to Kushner Cos., which is headed by the family of President Trump's son-in-law Jared Kushner. He ran for council pledging to take on real-estate developers.
Solomon's election victory was a stunner, even for some of his supporters who confessed they started the day sure he would lose. On Nov. 7, Solomon came in second against four opponents, landing 735 votes behind first-place finisher Rebecca Symes, a 36-year-old attorney. In Jersey City it's rare for a runner-up to win the second round.
During the four-week runoff campaign, most of the city's political establishment endorsed Symes, including all three at-large council members, County Clerk-elect E. Junior Maldonado (the ex-councilman Fulop unseated in 2005) and Assemblywoman Angela McKnight. A group tied to a labor union backing Symes spent tens of thousands of dollars on polling and a television commercial. Fulop stayed neutral.
After all the votes were counted on Tuesday, Solomon bested Symes by 249 votes. He lost less than 10 percent of his vote total between the first round and the runoff. Symes' drop-off was almost 40 percent.
One longtime political observer credited the light turnout -- 4,107 voters cast ballots, 16 percent of Downtown's registered voters -- saying only the "zealots" came out, and they went heavy for Solomon. Robin Logsdon, Solomon's campaign manager, said the councilman-elect's message resonated with voters.
"I give immense credit to this team and James and our voters, that they believed in the implausible outcome that they could win against the machine," he said. "They believed it strongly enough to work that hard for it and it happened."
Solomon also spent a lot of money. In late November his campaign reported spending $151,585, while Symes spent $113,768 (the pro-labor group shelled out at least $43,700 on behalf of Symes). Solomon also loaned his campaign $35,000, which is more than the council salary.
Solomon defended his campaign spending, saying "to take that machine on generally requires money." He also noted that Fulop's eight-person council term reported spending more than $600,000 total before the general election, making his own spending "not wildly out of line."
With Fulop winning re-election with a record vote share, Solomon's victory was a bright spot for longtime Fulop foes and ex-fans of the mayor who have become his critics. One of them, Ellen Simon, a former school board member, called Solomon a "stand-up guy" who ran a campaign that did not veer from its core principles.
Simon said she knows of one flaw: "I say this as an Ohio native: Sadly, he is a Steelers fan."
Terrence T. McDonald may be reached at tmcdonald@jjournal.com. Follow him on Twitter @terrencemcd. Find The Jersey Journal on Facebook.